ARTICLE BY NIVEDITA GUNTURI
Since I moved to India, I’ve found that public awareness of true social conditions is sorely lacking, in the non-humanitarian circles at least. Thorough journalism and a global commitment to turning awareness into a social epidemic might do something to move us in the correct direction.
I came across a book in which the author attempts to do just this, getting the word out to as many people as possible. P. Sainath, a journalist, received a grant from The Times of India to travel across the country, revealing the hidden injustices that the poorest of the poor suffer in India. He did a phenomenal job, creating a volume that anyone with any vested interest in social work in India must read. His work is investigative journalism at its best, filled with everything from statistics to case studies to thorough, incisive interviews.
The author covers a host of topics, which I’ll list here so that readers can have a better idea of what the book actually contains:
Health Care
Sainath talks about the state of rural health care and the shortage of doctors for the poor. He asks biting questions about why a poor child does not deserve the same care that a better-off child gets. Important reading for any one wanting to go into public health anywhere in the world, and especially in South Asia.
Education
The dismal state of education in India is covered here. This chapter left me feeling that a proper education is vital to the improvement of the state of affairs here in India.
Displacement
It is particularly heartbreaking to read of how adivasis (tribals) are being summarily thrown out of their homes with little to no promise of compensation. The truly dismal part of this is that their homes and villages are being used for weapon testing and target practice by the military. It is shameful and despicable that a nation can treat its own citizens like this. Of course this is not the only place in the world that this has happened, but that does not make it acceptable.
Survival Strategies
This chapter is at once uplifting and tragic, as we see what the poor of India have been doing to improve their lot in life.
Crime
This part of the book looks at what kinds of crimes have been committed against the poor and the utter, shocking, lack of response from the Indian justice system.
Water
This chapter describes the lengths many in India have to go to to find water for daily use and how dependent they are on others for their water supply.
Media
This is a particularly important and especially impressive part of the book, I feel, because Sainath takes a moment to cast a critical eye on the media and journalists, of whom he is one. He talks about how journalism takes a view that is either sympathetic to the government or speaks highly of NGO’s. He argues that neither is helping the poor. He also reveals the sheer number of NGO’s which have been accused of corruption and have embezzled funds donated to the poor.
Overall, Everybody Loves a Good Drought is a true eye-opener, in many senses, and should be required reading for anyone wanting to work for India’s poor or India’s children. Although it is now twelve years old, I think the examples and causes delineated in the book are still 100% valid.
I’ve given an excerpt here from the chapter on health and health care, because it particularly hit home with me. I hope that it gives you a good idea of the tone and feel of Sainath’s book.
“Tuberculosis claims over 450,000 Indian lives each year. It would be lucky to get a couple of columns in the newspapers yearly. If it does, it’s when the country’s distinguished chest physicians, some of whom treat newspaper proprietors, hold their annual congress.
Diarrhoea claims close to 1.5 million infants each year in this country, one every three minutes. The best it can get by way of space is when UNICEF’s annual “State of The World Children’s Report” is released. Then it makes an occasional bow on the centre page. Or, in one of those anguished editorials (hastily written because the one on the Stock Exchange didn’t turn up) asking: “Where Have We Gone Wrong?” After which, it can be packed away to be used in identical form the following year. If no Indian has won a beauty contest that season, it could even make the front page. This establishes that the newspaper has a caring editor, who will soon address the Rotary Club on What Can Be Done For Our Children.
Every fourteen days, over 7.5 million children below the age of five in India suffer from diarrhoea. Close to nineteen million contract acute respiratory infections including pneumonia, in the same 336 hours. Quite a lot can be done for them, but it isn’t.
In 1992, USAID gave India Rs. 12.6 billion to be spent solely on population control in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh. This program has serious implications. One is that hazardous contraceptives like Norplant will be pushed onto very poor rural women who have little or no access to proper health care. The same contraceptives are not in general use in any Western country.
Funds are much harder to come by for, say, water-borne diseases which account for nearly 80 percent of India’s public health problems and claim millions of lives yearly. These include diarrhoea, dysentery, typhoid, cholera, and infectious hepatitis. Water-related diseases, including malaria, take their toll in tens of thousands of human lives annually.
Yet every third human being in the world without safe and adequate water supply is an Indian. Every fourth child in the globe who dies of diarrheal disease is an Indian. Every third person in the world with leprosy is an Indian. Every fourth being in the planet dying of water-borne or water-related diseases is an Indian. Of the over sixteen million cases of tuberculosis that exist at any time worldwide, 12.7 million are Indian. Tens of millions of Indians suffer from malnutrition. Yet, official expenditure on nutrition is less than one percent of GNP.”
One point that particularly struck me were that only 20% of hospital beds are in rural areas, where 80% of the population lives. I have heard varying versions of this statistic, but it’s always been just as drastically disproportionate as this version makes it out to be.
One particularly biting statement Sainath makes is that the Indian government is trying the ‘trickle down theory – take away from the poor, give to the rich, see how much trickles down to the poor.’ He remarks that the result is that ‘money trickles up, malaria trickles down.’
From my blog, Informed Activism in India.